11 March 2021
Historians on Trial
On 9 February 2021, the District Court in Warsaw ruled that two prominent Holocaust researchers must publicly apologize for statements published in a book about the extermination of Jews in Nazi Germany-occupied Poland during the Second World War. The lawsuit is an example of strategic litigation aimed at intimidating researchers and exercising a chilling effect on the debate in Poland due to the involvement of an organization close to the government and framing of the case in pro-government public and private media. In March, courts in Poland handed judgments in two other important strategic lawsuits brought on criminal charges. Continue reading >>
1 
08 February 2021
Between Rule of Law and Reputation
On 27 January, Frontex announced the unprecedented decision to suspend its activities in Hungary. The choice to withdraw the Agency from Hungary is not a clear, serious, and meditated move in the Commission’s action for the rule of law. Nor is it a sign of a coherent and firm intention to put an end to the Agency’s engagement in human rights violations at EU borders, since it keeps operating in other frontline Member States with equally problematic issues. It rather represents an attempt to remedy the already compromised reputation of Frontex. Continue reading >>
0
05 February 2021
Loyalty, Opportunism and Fear
The pressure on universities and academic freedom in Hungary is increasing. With a reform program initiated in 2019, the government has started to restructure universities, from a state-funded to a privately-funded model. At the end of the current round of restructuring in 2021, there will be more private universities than public ones. While universities officially have to request their privatisation to start the process, it is clear that the aim of the reform is to forcefully reduce the independence of universities. In January, a number of universities were given an ultimatum until the end of the month to decide on their transformation. Continue reading >>
0
27 January 2021
‘Laws of Fear’ in the EU
COVID-19 has demonstrated the fragility of EU free movement rules when faced with an unknown virus of such magnitude and strength, while raising the issues of power, solidarity and trust in the system. The fear of COVID-19 has also had a strong impact on the application of two principles in EU free movement law: the principle of proportionality and the precautionary principle. The pandemic has had a transformative effect on the application of these principles. Continue reading >>
0
05 January 2021
Dancing with the Dragon
On 30 December 2020, the EU Commission announced that the EU and China “in principle” concluded the negotiations on a Comprehensive Agreement on Investment (CAI). So far, there has only been a limited assessment of the CAI from a human rights perspective which is problematic considering recent political developments in China. This leads to the question: How does the CAI measure against the standards of the constitutional law of the EU relating to its external relations? Moreover, it is doubtful that the agreement will meet the requirements prescribed by the European Parliament in this regard. Continue reading >>02 December 2020
Selbstbestimmung statt Fremdbestimmung
Mitte November eskalierte der Konflikt zwischen Marokko und der Westsahara nach dreißig Jahren Waffenruhe. Die Rolle, die die EU in den letzten Jahren in der Region eingenommen hat, zeigt, dass hier hauptsächlich wirtschaftliche Interessen zählen. Wie vom EuGH bestätigt stützt der aktuelle Kurs der EU die marokkanischen Souveränitätsansprüche und perpetuiert damit den völkerrechtswidrigen Zustand in der Westsahara. Continue reading >>24 November 2020
EU-Finanzsanktionen für Rechtsstaatsverstöße
Seit Jahren fordern Politiker und Wissenschaftler einen Mechanismus zum Schutz der Rechtsstaatlichkeit bei der Verwendung von EU-Mitteln. Ein Handeln der EU ist dringend, da sich die Lage der Rechtsstaatlichkeit, insbesondere in Polen und Ungarn weiter verschlechtert und die laufenden Verfahren nach Art. 7 EUV keine Wirkung zeigen. In Deutschland wird ein solcher Sanktionsmechanismus nicht zur Anwendung kommen. Continue reading >>
0
25 June 2020
Was ist die europäische Rechtsgemeinschaft? Nichts. Alles!
Spätestens mit dem PSPP-Urteil ist die „Rechtsgemeinschaft“ zu einem europarechtlichen Grundbegriff aufgestiegen. Die Berufung auf diesen Ausdruck ist ein theoretischer Reflexionsstop. Der Beitrag geht Sprachspielen nach und stellt aus rechtshistorischer Perspektive die These auf, dass unter „Rechtsgemeinschaft“ ein Primat der Praxis verhandelt wird. Continue reading >>
0
14 September 2018
How likely – and dangerous – is a Kosovo/Serbia “Land Swap” ?
The presidents of Kosovo and Serbia have recently considered an exchange of territories (“land swap”) between their two countries which would lead to Serbia’s formal recognition of the independence of Kosovo. In view of legal and politcial hurdles, one can envisage at least three distinct scenarios of international response to a bilateral treaty between Serbia and Kosovo, concerning specific synchronized border changes. Continue reading >>25 June 2018