Devyani Prabhat

A Paean to Judicial (Self) Restraint

The UK Supreme Court Shamima Begum decision is widely reported to be a win for former home secretary Sajid Javid who had stripped Begum of her citizenship. Yet, is it really a vindication of this action? The decision of the Supreme Court is not based on a factual assessment of Begum’s case but only on whether she has to be given permission to return to the UK to participate in an effective and fair manner in the immigration appeal. A limited decision, and by no means a final adjudication on Begum’s deprivation of citizenship case. Continue reading >>

Kyra Wigard, Arthur Dyevre

Judges vs the Executive Branch

Last Friday, the Dutch Appeal Court of The Hague overturned a judgment of the District Court of the Hague which had made headlines in the Low Countries and beyond by enjoining an immediate end to the curfew imposed by the government to curb coronavirus infections. The case illustrates in dramatic fashion the tensions arising from the necessity to balance freedom and public health while tying into the more institutional question of the separation of powers between the judicial and executive branch. At the same time, the case casts light on the growing assertiveness of Dutch courts on matters of general policy-making. Continue reading >>

Martijn van den Brink

Preserving Prejudice in the Name of Profit

Few CJEU judgments in recent years have received more criticism than the ‘headscarf judgments’, Achbita and Bougnaoui. In particular the decision in Achbita that private employers can legitimately pursue a policy of neutrality and ban expressions of political, religious, or philosophical belief at work, proved contentious. Two other headscarf cases, IX v Wabe and MH Müller, are currently pending before the CJEU and provide it with an excellent opportunity to do so. However, the first signs are not promising: Last week, Advocate General Rantos delivered his Opinion in these cases, which may be even more unpalatable than the Achbita judgment itself. Continue reading >>

Franz Christian Ebert

Durchsetzungsunfähig

Am 18. Februar hat die EU-Kommission unter dem Titel „An Open, Sustainable and Assertive Trade Policy“ ihre Handelsstrategie für die kommenden Jahre veröffentlicht. Eine Priorität liegt dabei auf der verbesserten Durchsetzung der Nachhaltigkeitskapitel in den EU-Handelsabkommen. Allerdings nehmen EU-Handelsabkommen diese Kapitel ausdrücklich von den üblichen Sanktionsmechanismen aus und eignen sich deshalb nicht dazu, Arbeitnehmerrechte oder Umweltschutzstandards effektiv durchzusetzen. Doch auch ohne Änderungen an den bestehenden Regelungen könnte die Kommission zeigen, dass sie ihr Versprechen eines nachhaltigen Welthandels ernst meint. Zivilgesellschaftliche Akteure spielen dabei eine wichtige Rolle. Continue reading >>

Alberto Alemanno

The EU Parliament’s Abdication on the Rule of Law (Regulation)

To paraphrase a previous blog entry by Scheppele, Pech and Kelemen, if the The Decline and Fall of the European Union is ever written, historians will conclude that not only the EU’s two key intergovernmental institutions – the European Council and the Council – should bear the greatest responsibility for the EU’s demise, but also the EU Parliament. Indeed, by failing to challenge the legality of the EUCO’s December conclusions encroaching upon its own prerogatives, the EU Parliament might have just become an enabler of the ongoing erosion of the rule of law across the Union. Paradoxically, it did so after relying on incomplete and partial opinion of its own legal service advising the Parliament to trade the respect of the rule of law away for political convenience. Continue reading >>

Thomas Perroud

A Witch Hunt In French Universities

At a time when French universities are struggling to deal with the epidemic, when students’ poverty should be a prime concern for the authorities, the French Minister of Higher Education, Research and Innovation, Frédérique Vidal, announced on a TV channel that she intends to set up an inquiry into “islamo-leftism” and postcolonialism in French universities. This reminds the attacks in the 1930s against the “judeo-masonic” lobby, attacks which ended up in the cleansing of universities when the Vichy Régime was established in 1940. Continue reading >>

A Political Impasse, and How to Get Out of It

At the end of January, EU Commission Vice-President Věra Jourová addressed a letter to a Spanish MEP. In this letter, the Commissioner, using diplomatic language, expressed her concern that the reform of the General Council of the Judiciary (CGPJ), initiated by the ruling Spanish left-wing coalition PSOE-Unidas Podemos in September, could diminish the independence of this governing body of the Judiciary and thus of all judges and courts. Continue reading >>

Aqilah Sandhu

Bezirksamt Berlin-Mitte contra Tagesschau

Es hagelte Kritik aus der Presse und der Deutsche Journalistenverband zeigte sich empört, nachdem das Bezirksamt Berlin-Mitte die Live-Übertragung einer Video-Pressekonferenz vom 17. Februar 2021, bei der die Ergebnisse einer Studie des Robert Koch-Instituts über die Verbreitung des Coronavirus vorgestellt wurden, verweigerte. Das wäre mit Blick auf die bekannten technischen Defizite der Verwaltung kein großer Aufreger, hätte das Bezirksamt dies nicht mit dem mittlerweile berüchtigten Datenschutz begründet. Diese Ausrede vermittelt den Eindruck, der Datenschutz sei nun auch noch ein Hemmschuh für die Pressefreiheit. Insofern ist der Fall exemplarisch für ein fehlgeleitetes Verständnis von Datenschutz und den ihm inzwischen – weitgehend zu Unrecht – anhaftenden zweifelhaften Ruf. Continue reading >>